Book 4 Predictions | Page 2 | Discuss Cormoran Strike! | Discuss

Avatar
Log In

Please consider registering
Guest

— Forum Scope —




— Match —





— Forum Options —





Min search length: 3 characters / Max search length: 84 characters

Register Lost password?
sp_TopicIcon
Book 4 Predictions
RSS
Avatar
United States
48 Posts
(Offline)
125
02/16/2018 - 5:06 pm

Kaqu said
I am reading the novels not as much for the crimes as for the development of the characters. There is so much backstory in all of them, and that's why I love it. I'm not really interested in crime, but I am interested in people and there are few writers who make their characters come to life as much as JK Rowling does.
I once described the Strike novels as a very very slow Jane Austen novel with a lot of murders in it Kiss  

Love the Jane Austen comparison! I personally enjoy every aspect of these stories -- the characters, the crime, the mystery, the colorful locations -- all of it. I can't imagine whittling down any component (less backstory, less description, etc.) without adversely affecting the wondrously engrossing entirety.

Avatar
72 Posts
(Offline)
124
02/15/2018 - 8:32 am

I am reading the novels not as much for the crimes as for the development of the characters. There is so much backstory in all of them, and that's why I love it. I'm not really interested in crime, but I am interested in people and there are few writers who make their characters come to life as much as JK Rowling does.
I once described the Strike novels as a very very slow Jane Austen novel with a lot of murders in it Kiss

Avatar
303 Posts
(Offline)
123
02/14/2018 - 11:07 pm

benedek said
It was not supposed to be a blame or anything! I just wanted to show that many seem to be reading the Strike novels more because of our heroes than because of the misteries. I am actually one of those. I think that there has been a good amount of personal life in the past books and there is going to be some in the future books as well.

But, once more, I am not saying that there will necessarily be a baby. 🙂  

Reading a crime novel because of the main characters and not because of the case is a wrong way to start reading one!

I like Cormoran and Robin very much but first of all I want a very good mystery!

When I say that I don't want Robin to marry Matthew it's first of all because I don't want a fourth book with the same drama of theirs! For crime novels I had enough of Matthew's bitching around and Robin not being happy with his behaviour during the first three books!

It will be completly different if Robin is single and starts a new life away from him because it will be something that we haven't read about until now and to read about some of the new things she will do besides work would be nice!
It would be also different if Robin leaves him at the altar and he goes crazy and starts tormenting Robin as a single woman or if they don't get married and at some point Matthew is in trouble and asks for their help and at the same time tries to cause problems in Cormoran's and Robin's relationship (if at the time they have one.)

Also if Charlotte never comes back to torment Cormoran it will be fine with me because I want to read the book because of the crime and how it's gonna be solved and not because I need more drama around their personal life.
I would find Charlotte's presence tolerateble if she is a client of theirs and also tries to win Cormoran over at that time for example.

You would ask me then why do I wish for Cormoran and Robin to get together since that also is personal, right?

Well Cormoran and Robin dating while solving crimes isn't going to add other characters so there wont be more drama just a couple in love that works together and is solving crimes that will face problems like any other couple. Some private moments here and there wont take much time from the case.

Now as you can see we have to deal with Cormoran's personal life and Robin's personal life that makes +2 people in the equation but if they are going to be together if there is any drama it will be only between the two of them.
I also believe they are right for each other and they will do good to one another if the get together.

Avatar
195 Posts
(Offline)
122
02/14/2018 - 8:32 pm

It was not supposed to be a blame or anything! I just wanted to show that many seem to be reading the Strike novels more because of our heroes than because of the misteries. I am actually one of those. I think that there has been a good amount of personal life in the past books and there is going to be some in the future books as well.

But, once more, I am not saying that there will necessarily be a baby. 🙂

Avatar
303 Posts
(Offline)
121
02/14/2018 - 12:06 pm

benedek said
Hmm, there are around twenty active people on this forum, hundreads of comments, but hardly any of them deal with the misteries. Practically, none of them. Notice, that you neither. 🙂  

Well if J.K Rowling would do the honor to let a cliff hanger about the actual case in one of her next books and not about personal affairs of her main characters I would be very pleased to discuss who I think the killer is!
The mystery is solved what could I possibly add to it at this point? But since I discovered this forum after reading the three books I will with great pleasure discuss about the crime of the fourth book when it's published! 🙂

Avatar
195 Posts
(Offline)
120
02/14/2018 - 11:49 am

Caitlin said

A photoshoot for a magazine isn't made the month or the week of it's publication so it might have been November's issue but that doesn't mean the interview and the photoshoot took place that exact month.

Yes, it probably takes some time but I don’t think it’s too much. My guess it’s a week the most. They want to be up to date.

And my question remains! Why not use this baby to pressure Cormoran to show up before she gets married as she did with the sms but instead of "was yours" she only had to use "is yours."

I see your point, and I don’t know the answer. Maybe Charlotte wanted to take things to the extreme. Why did she wait with the “was yours” until the wedding day? Maybe she just went crazy and only thinks about hurting Strike the most. Maybe the baby is actually not Strike’s, she’ll just claim it’s his? Maybe she doesn’t want the baby and they are not “out” with it, maybe it has some disability (mental?) and want to hide it from the world, keep it in an institution? (In that certain dream the baby had allegedly something wrong with it.) It could allow Rowling to bring in her favourite subject of institutionized children. And, of course, maybe there is no baby at all. 🙂

Also I can't but insist that a crime novel isn't a place for honeymoon scenes or paternity issue drama and if J.K Rowling wants to write about such things she should start wrting different genre novels. God I'm starting to miss Agatha Christie style crime novels!

Hmm, there are around twenty active people on this forum, hundreads of comments, but hardly any of them deal with the misteries. Practically, none of them. Notice, that you neither. 🙂

Avatar
303 Posts
(Offline)
119
02/14/2018 - 11:17 am

benedek said
I bring the discussion about Charlotte’s baby here as I think it is rather out of topic under “Lethal white publication”.

spotlessmind said

I seem to remember that some high society magazine published an engagement photo spread about Jago Ross and Charlotte's marriage. If she was pregnant (far enough along to know it at the start, when Cormoran breaks up with her) it would be pretty difficult to conceal it for very long under that sort of public scrutiny ... although, according to the timeline, everything including Charlotte's wedding happens within the space of a couple of months.

My thinking is that Charlotte and Jago were not under constant scrutiny by the press, it was only one article in the Tatler magazine where they were featured, right before the wedding. (Otherwise you are certainly right and a pregnancy should have been apparent.)

As to the timeline: once I put it together for myself (and even shared it on this site). I copy it here:

“Charlotte first told Strike that she was pregnant one month before they broke up. As they broke up on the 28th of March, it was late February, meaning that the first day of her last period was probably around late January. If I put this date in a pregnancy due date calculator, it gives me early November. Strike learnt about her wedding and bought the Tatler magazine on the 24th of November.”

So by the time of the article (on or 1-2 days before the 24th of November) the baby (if any, of course) should have already been born.

But don’t get me wrong. It’s not that I’m convinced about the baby. It’s merely something that I find possible. Just bcause of two things: this exact timeline, and that very lively dream of Strike about the baby.  

A photoshoot for a magazine isn't made the month or the week of it's publication so it might have been November's issue but that doesn't mean the interview and the photoshoot took place that exact month.

And my question remains! Why not use this baby to pressure Cormoran to show up before she gets married as she did with the sms but instead of "was yours" she only had to use "is yours." It would the perfect way to make him go for sure and "save" her from Jago and as Charlotte is described I doubt she would lose the opportunity to use it in her favour.

Also I can't but insist that a crime novel isn't a place for honeymoon scenes or paternity issue drama and if J.K Rowling wants to write about such things she should start wrting different genre novels. God I'm starting to miss Agatha Christie style crime novels!

Avatar
195 Posts
(Offline)
118
02/14/2018 - 10:34 am

I bring the discussion about Charlotte’s baby here as I think it is rather out of topic under “Lethal white publication”.

spotlessmind said

I seem to remember that some high society magazine published an engagement photo spread about Jago Ross and Charlotte's marriage. If she was pregnant (far enough along to know it at the start, when Cormoran breaks up with her) it would be pretty difficult to conceal it for very long under that sort of public scrutiny ... although, according to the timeline, everything including Charlotte's wedding happens within the space of a couple of months.

My thinking is that Charlotte and Jago were not under constant scrutiny by the press, it was only one article in the Tatler magazine where they were featured, right before the wedding. (Otherwise you are certainly right and a pregnancy should have been apparent.)

As to the timeline: once I put it together for myself (and even shared it on this site). I copy it here:

“Charlotte first told Strike that she was pregnant one month before they broke up. As they broke up on the 28th of March, it was late February, meaning that the first day of her last period was probably around late January. If I put this date in a pregnancy due date calculator, it gives me early November. Strike learnt about her wedding and bought the Tatler magazine on the 24th of November.”

So by the time of the article (on or 1-2 days before the 24th of November) the baby (if any, of course) should have already been born.

But don’t get me wrong. It’s not that I’m convinced about the baby. It’s merely something that I find possible. Just bcause of two things: this exact timeline, and that very lively dream of Strike about the baby.

Avatar
44 Posts
(Offline)
117
02/06/2018 - 1:30 pm

Leafling said

I agree with everything you wrote, but when you say "assistant" I picture someone answering emails and phone calls.  

I know which just makes it more funny.

Avatar
110 Posts
(Offline)
116
02/05/2018 - 10:36 am

Impulse said

I think shanker is definitely going to be involved with the investigation now, and if something goes down at the wedding he will definitely be involved in the next case.
I was just thinking about his reaction the last couple if chapters of coe, and how he helped both cormoran and robin to bring someone down.
I think he's really up for it and he can still be shady and have friends, I actually see him more of an assistant who just comes in when he wants too lol.
I think by his reaction that bringing these people down gives him the same buzz as when he's doing his shady stuff, I can just see him being like I didn't realise there was so much paperwork and stuff and him just ending up doing the more physical stuff.  

I agree with everything you wrote, but when you say "assistant" I picture someone answering emails and phone calls.

Avatar
44 Posts
(Offline)
115
02/05/2018 - 10:29 am

Leafling said
I just can't see Shanker being an assistant. Ha is a shady guy with shady dealings and he loves that life, he is not the type of character that will want to change. Also, he is Strike the best connection to the underbelly of London, they would not want to lose that.

I think is much more likely that Alyssia will stay on as an assistant and true her Shanker will be a more permanent fixture in the office?  

I think shanker is definitely going to be involved with the investigation now, and if something goes down at the wedding he will definitely be involved in the next case.
I was just thinking about his reaction the last couple if chapters of coe, and how he helped both cormoran and robin to bring someone down.
I think he's really up for it and he can still be shady and have friends, I actually see him more of an assistant who just comes in when he wants too lol.
I think by his reaction that bringing these people down gives him the same buzz as when he's doing his shady stuff, I can just see him being like I didn't realise there was so much paperwork and stuff and him just ending up doing the more physical stuff.

Avatar
110 Posts
(Offline)
114
02/05/2018 - 7:54 am

Impulse said
I'm going to re post something here that didn't belong in another thread I posted it in lol, sorry about that.
See I was reading some of career of evil the other day and I think Shanker! could be the new assistant we were teased.
And I reckon Robin will move in with Ekwenzi and finally have a friend to gossip with and stuff. And I think it will be better this way, or maybe it's a house share and they're living together that way. I want Robin to have a genuine friend and feel this is a better way.
Plus when I noticed how in awe Shanker was in the showdown in coe and his seemingly new admiration for strike, I just couldn't get the idea out of my head he will be the new assistant, I think it could be great.
I think the set up will be better this way, but I'm probably completely wrong lol.  

I just can't see Shanker being an assistant. Ha is a shady guy with shady dealings and he loves that life, he is not the type of character that will want to change. Also, he is Strike the best connection to the underbelly of London, they would not want to lose that.

I think is much more likely that Alyssia will stay on as an assistant and true her Shanker will be a more permanent fixture in the office?

Avatar
44 Posts
(Offline)
113
02/05/2018 - 12:03 am

I'm going to re post something here that didn't belong in another thread I posted it in lol, sorry about that.
See I was reading some of career of evil the other day and I think Shanker! could be the new assistant we were teased.
And I reckon Robin will move in with Ekwenzi and finally have a friend to gossip with and stuff. And I think it will be better this way, or maybe it's a house share and they're living together that way. I want Robin to have a genuine friend and feel this is a better way.
Plus when I noticed how in awe Shanker was in the showdown in coe and his seemingly new admiration for strike, I just couldn't get the idea out of my head he will be the new assistant, I think it could be great.
I think the set up will be better this way, but I'm probably completely wrong lol.

Avatar
EU
99 Posts
(Offline)
112
02/04/2018 - 10:33 pm

Been thinking about how we could rescue Robin, in case she actually does go through with the vows and everything. So, I've looked up the annulment laws in the UK and there seem to be several options left, even after the "i do" (and in case this is where JKR is heading, I have a feeling that our favourite detective KNOWS about stuff like that - or he will be smart and call Ilsa and she can save the day):

2. Your marriage is defective - ‘voidable’ marriages
You can annul a marriage if:

A) it wasn’t consummated - you haven’t had sex with the person you married since the wedding (doesn’t apply for same sex couples)

That seems VERY likely to me. They will be rowing, Robin will be crying, there will be no sex.

B) you didn’t properly consent to the marriage - eg you were drunk or forced into it

Matt being the manipulating wanker that he is, this also seems like a realistic solution to me.

C) the other person had a sexually transmitted disease when you got married

Maybe less likely, but indefinitely more satisfying (haha) because not only will he be exposed as the lying arsehole he it, but his (possible) cheating will come back to haunt him in the most poetic way.

You can look up everything here: https://www.gov.uk/how-to-annul-marriage

wit beyond measure is man's greatest treasure

Avatar
303 Posts
(Offline)
111
02/04/2018 - 6:06 pm

Kalliope said
Funny you should ask that, because I've been thinking about that for some time.
I do believe that Matt loves Robin, BUT we all know that people even cheat on their loved ones, especially when there's conflict, or they have self-worth issues, or are when thy're generally narcissistic. And we know he did it primarily to feel good about himself, because he felt rejected by Robin.

I believe his love is misplaced! I do understand that it's an issue of someone's character to cheat or not but Matthew loves the image he has for Robin they way she used to be after her abuse! He doesn't like what she really is and it started to show the moment she started to do something she loves!

Kalliope said
It might be a possibilty that he'd slept with her even after uni. I thought that at some point she'd asked him directly whether it had only happened then; but i checked and that never actually happened. He only wrote in his text message that it was only one time (for 18 months), and it hadn't happened since. So, I do think there's a possibility he'd slept with Sarah when she and Strike were on their trip to Barrow, after she declines to go to his father's birthday. Because that's when he stopped texting her.  

Despite the fact that J.K Rowling used the word "imagination" at that point in The Silkworm where after their fight Robin slept in the sofa and the next day went early to work to avoid him his thought made me think that he might cheat on her every time his ego is at his low!
He thought of Robin going to the building but instead of going to the office she went to Cormoran's flat where he was expecting her to cheat on him because they had a fight!
I don't know though if it's because of his previous actions or because it's something he does the times he has problems with Robin!

Avatar
EU
99 Posts
(Offline)
110
02/04/2018 - 5:47 pm

Caitlin said

Thanks! I couldn't remember about that at all!
I agree that it's stupid! She wouldn't want her presence in Matthew's life if she had found earlier about their affair!
In your personal opinion do you believe that Matthew kept having intimate relations with Sarah when things weren't good in his relationship with Robin?
Might be the reason as to why they are still close and why Sarah is so obsessed with him....  

Funny you should ask that, because I've been thinking about that for some time. I do believe that Matt loves Robin, BUT we all know that people even cheat on their loved ones, especially when there's conflict, or they have self-worth issues, or are when thy're generally narcissistic. And we know he did it primarily to feel good about himself, because he felt rejected by Robin.

It might be a possibilty that he'd slept with her even after uni. I thought that at some point she'd asked him directly whether it had only happened then; but i checked and that never actually happened. He only wrote in his text message that it was only one time (for 18 months), and it hadn't happened since. So, I do think there's a possibility he'd slept with Sarah when she and Strike were on their trip to Barrow, after she declines to go to his father's birthday. Because that's when he stopped texting her.

wit beyond measure is man's greatest treasure

Avatar
303 Posts
(Offline)
109
02/04/2018 - 5:10 pm

Kalliope said

Yes, Robin decides against disinviting Sarah, because she does not want to show that she _only just_ found out about their affair.
Pretty stupid, if you ask me, as Matthew probably told Sarah at some point that Robin doesn't know about their history (especially since they had a row about Robin not wanting to have Sarah at the wedding in the first place at the beginning of the SW).  

Thanks! I couldn't remember about that at all!
I agree that it's stupid! She wouldn't want her presence in Matthew's life if she had found earlier about their affair!
In your personal opinion do you believe that Matthew kept having intimate relations with Sarah when things weren't good in his relationship with Robin?
Might be the reason as to why they are still close and why Sarah is so obsessed with him....

Avatar
EU
99 Posts
(Offline)
108
02/04/2018 - 5:04 pm

Caitlin said

Kalliope do you remember why Sarah is still invited in the wedding after Robin found out about her affair with Matthew? Did Robin ever mentioned she didn't want her there or she didn't care at all?
Career of evil is the one book of the series I can't re-read because of the end ok and because of the middle and I can't recall some things. 🙂  

Yes, Robin decides against disinviting Sarah, because she does not want to show that she _only just_ found out about their affair.
Pretty stupid, if you ask me, as Matthew probably told Sarah at some point that Robin doesn't know about their history (especially since they had a row about Robin not wanting to have Sarah at the wedding in the first place at the beginning of the SW).

wit beyond measure is man's greatest treasure

Avatar
303 Posts
(Offline)
107
02/04/2018 - 4:38 pm

Kalliope said

It's mentioned in chapter 11, that Ilsa likes robin, and between the lines it's apparent that they must've met (and probably a couple more of his friends, who "called in at the office")  

Kalliope do you remember why Sarah is still invited in the wedding after Robin found out about her affair with Matthew? Did Robin ever mentioned she didn't want her there or she didn't care at all?
Career of evil is the one book of the series I can't re-read because of the end ok and because of the middle and I can't recall some things. 🙂

Avatar
EU
99 Posts
(Offline)
106
02/04/2018 - 4:20 pm

Caitlin said

I would imagine J.K Rowling would write an actual scene where Robin meets Cormoran's best friends and from the translation I didn't get the fact that they actually have met! I always thought Ilsa knew about Robin only from things Cormoran has said to them anyway I hope then on an actual scene where they will spend time together and have some fun even if Robin and Cormoran are not a couple (yet)  

It's mentioned in chapter 11, that Ilsa likes robin, and between the lines it's apparent that they must've met (and probably a couple more of his friends, who "called in at the office")

wit beyond measure is man's greatest treasure

Forum Timezone: UTC 0
All RSS Show Stats

Top Posters:

Caitlin: 303

benedek: 195

Leafling: 110

Kalliope: 99

DonnaN: 88

LindMea: 83

Kaqu: 72

spotlessmind: 48

Impulse: 44

Pamela Fizler: 39

Forum Stats:

Groups: 2

Forums: 6

Topics: 198

Posts: 1672

 

Member Stats:

Guest Posters: 49

Members: 358

Moderators: 0

Admins: 3

Most Users Ever Online: 27

Currently Online:
3 Guest(s)

Currently Browsing this Page:
1 Guest(s)